Cheaters, Liars, and Whiners: The Washington Coast Wrap-up

In Washington by Jonathan Stumpf7 Comments

Washington Coast spoon-fed wild steelhead.
Image: Lee Geist

Wild Steelheaders United ambassador Lee Geist shares his perspective from a season chasing steelhead on Washington’s coast under new fishing regulations meant to reduce angler encounter rate. Follow Lee on Instagram @lee_geist for field reports, steelheading tips and tactics, and the latest steelhead conservation updates.

Washington’s coastal recreational winter steelhead fishery was quite different this season. A dismal run forecast, following years of declining adult returns to Olympic Peninsula (OP) and Chehalis Basin rivers, required the Washington Department of Fish and Wildlife (WDFW) to restrict angling like never before.

The new rules were no fishing from a floating device, single point barbless hooks, and artificial lures only. WDFW even put the kibosh on the old two-rigs-on-one-leader trick. These new regulations applied to every stream in this region, including such legendary waters as Hoh, Sol Duc, and Humptulips rivers and were intended to reduce angling encounter rates.

They succeeded. And if we are truly committed to steelhead conservation, we should all be happy about that. Anyone who thinks encounter rates of 1.5-times per fish per season (on some OP rivers) don’t have an effect on steelhead energy reserves and possibly spawning success is fooling themselves.

After the run size in Grays Harbor and Willapa Bay came up even smaller than projected, those rivers were closed early. An early closure on rivers in the northernmost part of the region went into effect the same day, moving the traditional closure date of April 15th to the last day in March.

The shortening of the winter steelhead fishing season was hard on anglers, guides, and local economies, but by far the most contentious management response to the poor returns forecasted this year was the ban on fishing from a floating device.

Being in the captain’s seat of a river boat has always been my niche. For some of us, using a pair of oars to set up the perfect drift is the stuff steelhead dreams are made of. That said, two modern-day steelheaders and an oarsman worth their salt have few obstacles between them and success.

Every nook, cranny, and hog trough will be thoroughly carved out. Every pocket will be probed and every run swept clean. Some of us will do this with two presentations through 10 or even 20 miles of river in a single day. Add a bead dropper or a bead off that yarn ball and suddenly four presentations are making their way through every inch of every lie. Add the newest and best steelhead angling technology and these critters will get caught.

I am accustomed to this style of fishing so the challenge presented by the new rules this season forced me to face an uncomfortable reality – that I have had my boot heel on the backs of these fish since the day I could row a drift boat. I am not going to pretend I don’t miss it. But I think it actually was a good thing for steelhead.

“Sooner or later quality fishing comes down to a limit on the number of participants and the things they are doing out there.”
-Bob Hooton

From the Bank

I spent the entire winter season fishing the Washington coast, where I have lived and fished my entire life. I am plenty familiar with the rivers here and bounced around quite a few this year. Being limited to fishing from the bank made managing time to cover water a challenge. Local knowledge excelled against this variable. Some sections of river hold steelhead year after year no matter how much they change; knowing these places was an advantage, to say the least.

My observation was that the angling pressure on the rivers I fished was cut in half this season. I had the most popular drifts on several rivers completely to myself. There is no doubt the local economy and guide community were impacted by this regulation. While I am not sure as to the extent of this impact, the guides I am acquainted with stayed positive and busy throughout the season.

The author landing a beautiful hen, barbless and from the bank.

Fewer anglers on the river may reduce encounter rates but it also reduces the number of potential advocates for steelhead. In times like these, when run sizes are so depressed, this seems an acceptable trade-off. I am positive that this season, with the new rules, a number of steelhead made it through to spawn without seeing a single hook, and that is nothing but good news.

And there were other benefits — the reduced angling pressure made the atmosphere more relaxed. Boat ramp conflict was at a minimum and other than some whining over the new rules, the general attitude on the river was positive.

The Challenges

When we could fish out of boats we spent more time on the river. This season, water events we would have considered fishable when floating were deemed too high. There were some places we simply could not reach during larger flows. Simply put, anglers had more difficulty intercepting steelhead during flows that would have been considered prime for side drifting or bobber dogging from a boat. In my experience, such conditions increase your encounter rate ten-fold.

One challenge I did not expect under the new rules was running out of bank just in time to get spooled by a slob. One day I lost a dandy whopper. The fish clamped onto my spoon at the top of a chute, just as big steelhead do, and immediately lost its mind. Somehow it ended up on the opposite side of the river thrashing in a few inches of water, only to flop back into the rapid and around the next corner. He left my girlfriend and me helpless on the tip of an island in the middle of the river.

Wet and wild with an Olympic Peninsula steelhead.
Image: Lee Geist

All it would have taken to grasp that caudle peduncle was a quick assist from the raft. But for what? A picture or some bragging rights? The best part of the game is the first few moments of connection. I’ve learned to laugh away the heartache of losing a fine steelhead.

The running-and-gunning aspect of fishing from a floating device was minimized this year, too. All of us anglers were suddenly on a pretty even playing field. Most of us spent time picking water apart and slowing down. Being the lead boat was pointless. I found myself putting in well after daylight, taking my time and using slower methods like spoons, drift gear, and swinging flies. The new rules imposed a bigger challenge and certainly decreased our encounter rate, but we always seemed to find a few even so.

“We fish steelhead for the challenge. I don’t care how hard they make it.”
– Carson Churchill

Most of the anglers I know embraced the challenges imposed by the new rules as another obstacle worth beating fair and square. Personally, I felt the new rule made things more interesting and upped the ante. Sadly, this feeling was not shared by all.

The Outlaws

Violations of the new regulations were common. Fishing from a floating device was rampant, unchallenged, and almost completely unchecked across the coast throughout the season. Excuses like “You got to do what you got to do,” “I didn’t get the memo,” or “You just can’t fish that river from the bank” were among many I heard this season. The greasiest among us spent time in lesser known tributaries and remote areas to flout the rules. Perhaps most disappointing was the number of guides who felt the new rules did not apply to them.

These anglers are not just breaking the law — they are cheating at the game and stealing opportunities from law-abiding anglers. Sure, more enforcement could have made a difference. Some rivers were monitored via drone, and a few citations were made, but WDFW officers are stretched far too thin to catch many of the bad actors and protecting steelhead is not their only responsibility.

Fishing and hunting require more self-control than other, less-consumptive outdoor activities. As a license holder you are required to practice “fair chase” and to make decisions that best support conservation of a precious and limited resource. Fishing teaches you many things, but maybe most importantly it reveals who you are when no one is looking. This winter steelhead season on the OP, some members of the angling community came up short in this regard.

Catch up on the new rules enacted by WDFW for the Washington coast this past winter steelhead season here and here, and learn more about why WDFW had to make these changes and how it was the best option for all anglers.  

Comments

  1. Looks like a duck, quacks like a duck, – it’s a duck. Call a poacher a poacher – period.

    1. Ya leaving jigs and hooks in the fish when spooled ensures survival…If you think about it, you fish holes much more efficiently when fishing from the bank, versus a quick run through a hole with a single pass.. I encountered more fish from the bank than from a boat, this WDFW experiment was a complete failure..as is typical with this organization these days…Failure!!!!!

  2. Thanks for that great piece of writing. The same rules that Oregon developed for the Deschutes River Steelhead run make so much sense. No fishing from the boat as this gives the fish the middle of the river to sneak by the anglers. Fishing with a single barbless hook means not many fish will be actually caught but the real thrill of steelhead fishing is the initial strike and seeing how the fish fights.

  3. I hope one day I can be as cool and prestigious as you guys.

  4. These regulations did nothing meaningful to help wild steelhead on the op this year. All this regulation did was alienate anglers and push good fisherman and advocates for these fish off the river

  5. I really liked your perspective on this regulation issue. My state of California has yet to adopt the ban on fishing from a boat/float vessel and it is way over due. I live in Mendocino County, I fish the Navarro River which is not a very large river at all. One cold winter morning bout 30 years ago I was bank fishing on the Navarro and I saw one of the first drift boats to go down the Navarro. They drifted through the hole where I was fishing, pulled their rods in and said hello. Now I had been struggling all week to even get a bite and so when I asked them how they were doing one of the guys leaned out and said “Had 9 hook-ups but we only netted 5 of them ” Well I damn near fell face first into the river, either this guy was an outright lier or they were simply better fishermen than yours truly, I was putting my money on the guys pants catching on fire after that whopper. But still, there was something about that odd looking boat that spiked my curiosity. So between casts I watched them as they positioned themselves at the head of a run just below me… “Nine Steelhead, pffftt, yeah sure whatever” I looked away as I reeled in my line to make another cast when I was startled out of my stupor by a bunch of loud noises and screams coming from the direction of that funny looking boat that just passed through here. I immediately reconized the familiar chaotic sounds of “fish on!!”
    After that I watched that drift boat for the better part of an hour
    and in that time I witnessed strike after strike as they inched that boat down river literally vacuuming the fish out of it.
    I was mad as hell because these guys and that boat were changing the rules of the game. The fish never even had a chance. By this method they never gave the steelhead a fighting chance and I was struck with a horrible realization that this was probably the beginning of the end for the steelhead in the Navarro River. The end to everything I had been taught, everything that seemed fair, everything I had held so dear in my heart in my pursuit of this magnificent silver fish called Steelhead. And I was right.
    Things were never the same on the Navarro nor was I.
    I often wonder what if there had been a ban put on drift boat fishing all those 30 years ago, perhaps….perhaps.

Leave a Comment